Who Keeps the Recoverable Depreciation Check?
You do, once you finish the repairs and show the insurer the receipts proving the work was done.
Free to compare
Your insurer first pays the actual cash value, the repair cost minus depreciation for the roof's age and wear. That check is yours to use right away. The recoverable depreciation, the difference between that and the full repair cost, sits with the insurer until you complete the work. Send the contractor's invoice or paid receipt, and that second check follows. Most policies set a deadline for this, often 180 days from the first payment, so check your declarations page or the claim paperwork for the exact window before it closes.
The recoverable depreciation holdback can run into the thousands, and it only becomes yours once repairs are finished inside the deadline your policy sets. A slow insurer or a vague answer about that deadline is a bad sign this early in a claim. If the renewal price on this policy has also climbed, it is worth checking what other insurers would pay out and charge before you renew.
What if the repairs cost less than the insurer estimated?
Sometimes a contractor does the job for less than the insurer's original estimate. Maybe a cheaper material worked just as well, or the scope turned out smaller than expected. In that case, the recoverable depreciation check is based on what the repair actually cost, not the original estimate. Send the final invoice, and the insurer pays out the depreciation tied to that lower amount. You don't get to keep the difference between the estimate and the actual cost as profit.
The reverse happens too. If the repairs end up costing more than the original estimate, often because the contractor found additional damage once the work started, you can go back to the insurer with the updated invoice. Bring supporting documentation along with it. Insurers will often supplement the claim if the added cost is tied to the same covered damage, but this isn't automatic. You usually need photos or a written explanation from the contractor about what was found and why it added to the cost.
What happens if you never finish the repairs, or decide not to, matters as well. If you take the actual cash value payment and choose not to do the work, the recoverable depreciation stays with the insurer. There's no requirement that you complete repairs. There's also no path to the second check without a paid invoice showing the work was done. Some homeowners use the actual cash value toward a different repair approach entirely, like a full roof replacement instead of a patch. That's allowed as long as the work is a covered repair under the claim.
If a contractor offers to handle the insurance paperwork directly, confirm who the recoverable depreciation check gets sent to and how that amount is settled against what you owe them. Some contractors arrange for the insurer to pay them directly once the job is done, which can make the process easier to track. Even then, ask to see the final paid invoice yourself. That document is what proves the work was completed, and you'll want it on hand for your own records if any question comes up later.
What counts as proof the repairs are done?
Insurers generally want something more specific than a contractor's quote or a handshake agreement. A paid invoice is the standard document, one that shows the work was actually completed and that money changed hands for it. An estimate alone, even a detailed one, usually won't release the second check, because an estimate just describes work that hasn't happened yet.
The invoice should match the scope of the original claim. If the adjuster's report covered roof shingles, flashing, and gutter damage, the invoice should reflect that same work, or explain any changes. A mismatch between what was approved and what the invoice shows can slow things down, since the insurer has to figure out whether the extra work relates to the original damage or is something unrelated the homeowner decided to add on.
Photos help but usually aren't enough on their own. Some insurers ask for before-and-after pictures alongside the invoice, especially for larger claims, since it gives them a visual record alongside the paperwork. If your contractor pulled a permit for the work, a copy of the closed permit can also serve as supporting proof, particularly for structural repairs where local inspection is part of the process anyway.
Keep copies of everything you send. Claims move through different adjusters and departments, and paperwork sometimes gets delayed or misplaced on the insurer's end. Having your own file of the invoice, photos, and any correspondence about the deadline means you're not stuck starting over if something needs to be resent. If the insurer disputes whether the work matches the claim, this is also the documentation you'll lean on to make your case.
Before you file the invoice away
Check your claim paperwork for the exact deadline to submit proof of completed repairs. Missing that window is the most common way homeowners lose the recoverable depreciation check entirely.
