Recoverable vs Non Recoverable Depreciation
Recoverable depreciation is paid back once you finish repairs. Non-recoverable depreciation you never get back, no matter what.
Free to compare
What your policy says
Whether depreciation is recoverable depends on the coverage you bought. Replacement cost coverage usually makes it recoverable. Actual cash value coverage makes it non-recoverable from the start. Your declarations page names which one applies, and some policies make roofs non-recoverable even under replacement cost.
How the first check works
The adjuster writes the full repair cost. Then depreciation gets subtracted for your roof or siding's age and wear, along with your deductible. What's left is the first check. The withheld depreciation is listed separately on the estimate, not hidden.
Getting the rest back
If your depreciation is recoverable, you have to actually complete the repairs and send proof, usually a contractor's invoice or receipt, before the second check is released. Most policies set a deadline for this, often six months to a year from the first payment.
If the numbers look off
An offer that's lower than expected is often depreciation at work, not a denial. Check the estimate for the depreciation line and the age it assumed for your roof or siding. If that age or condition is wrong, that's grounds to ask the insurer to recalculate.
If your roof or siding ends up non-recoverable depreciation, or your policy is actual cash value, that gap between the first check and full repair cost is money you're covering yourself. A replacement cost policy with recoverable depreciation gets it back. That difference shows up at renewal too, so it's worth checking what another insurer would pay before this happens again.
How depreciation gets calculated in the first place
Depreciation is figured separately for each item on the estimate, not as one flat percentage off the top. A roof, the siding, the gutters, and the flooring inside all depreciate on their own schedule based on their own age and expected lifespan. A 12-year-old roof with a 25-year expected life has depreciated differently than vinyl siding installed the same year with a 40-year life. The adjuster's estimate should show each item broken out this way, with its own age, its own condition, and its own percentage withheld.
The method behind the number is usually straight-line depreciation. The item's expected lifespan divided into its age gives a percentage, and that percentage of the replacement cost gets withheld. A roof expected to last 25 years that is 10 years old has used 40 percent of its life, so roughly 40 percent of the cost to replace it gets held back as depreciation. Two roofs of the same size can end up with very different depreciation amounts. One that's 20 years old has far less value left to lose than one that's 5 years old.
Condition matters alongside age. An adjuster who notes your roof as being in poor condition for its age may apply heavier depreciation than the straight age-based math would suggest, and the reverse is true if it's been well maintained. If the estimate lists a condition that doesn't match reality, like calling a recently resealed roof worn, that's a specific, fixable error worth raising, separate from disputing the depreciation method itself.
Labor is sometimes depreciated along with materials, and sometimes it isn't. Some insurers withhold depreciation only on the materials portion of a repair, since labor doesn't wear out the way a roof does. Others depreciate the full line item, labor included. This varies by insurer and by state, and it changes how much of the first check you actually receive. The itemized estimate should show whether labor was depreciated. If that isn't clear from the paperwork, it's a direct question worth asking before assuming the total is correct.
What to do if the insurer won't pay the second check
Insurers sometimes delay or refuse the recoverable depreciation payment even after repairs are done. The most common reason is paperwork. The invoice or receipt sent as proof doesn't match the scope of work the adjuster originally estimated, or it's missing a signature, a date, or an itemized breakdown. Before assuming the insurer is stalling, check the proof you sent against what the estimate listed. A mismatch there is usually fixable with a corrected invoice from the contractor.
Timing causes the other common holdup. Most policies set a window, often six months to a year, for completing repairs and submitting proof. If repairs ran long because of a contractor's schedule or a materials delay, some insurers will grant an extension if asked before the deadline passes, not after. Waiting until the deadline has already slipped makes the request much harder to win, so it's worth calling as soon as a delay looks likely rather than once it's happened.
If the paperwork is in order and the deadline was met, and the insurer still hasn't released the check, the next step is a written request citing the policy's own language on recoverable depreciation, sent to the claims department rather than a single adjuster. Policies describe exactly when the second payment is owed, and pointing to that section directly tends to move things faster than a general complaint. Keep a copy of everything sent and the date it was sent.
If that doesn't resolve it, every state has an insurance department that handles complaints against insurers, and filing one costs nothing. These departments can't force a particular outcome, but they do contact the insurer directly and ask for a response, which often prompts movement on a claim that's been sitting. This step makes sense once direct requests have failed, not as the first move, since most delays get sorted out through the claims department itself.
Before you file anything else
Pull your declarations page and find your roof and siding's listed age and condition. If the adjuster's estimate doesn't match it, that's the first thing to challenge, before the first check even arrives.
